Tuesday, May 3, 2011

Who rescues the rescuers?

If I posted up tomorrow here on this blog or on Facebook or wherever that I was overwhelmed, things were not going well at the rescue, funds were low, I was in over my head, I felt I really needed help, it would be interesting to see just how many people in the animal rescue community would step up to the plate and offer genuine help and support. I'd like to think many would, but I wonder.

Who rescues the rescuers? In the light of recent events, it's a question that needs to be asked. What happened in Cork is wrong on so many levels, yet it's a good opportunity to take a look at the world of animal rescue and see how things can and do go wrong so easily from the best of intentions.

Running a private animal rescue in Ireland is extremely rewarding but also immensely challenging. Looking in from the outside, it must look wonderful and very appealing to some people. Devoting your time and energy to taking in the waifs and strays, nursing them back to health and finding them new forever homes where they will be loved and cherished. But it is much more than that. Running an animal rescue is also about fundraising, marketing, public relations, people skills, communication skills, creativity and computer knowledge. If you're lucky you'll find wonderful volunteers who will help with all of the above free of charge, if not, you have to do it yourself.

Animal rescue is also about endless cleaning of pee, poop, vomit, snot and hairballs. It's about having a basic understanding of the animal you are rescuing and some knowledge of disease and infection control.

I believe most of us start out with the very best intentions. Unfortunately there is no manual to tell you what to expect when you set up a private animal rescue, so it can come as a shock when your phone starts ringing non-stop with calls from the public requesting help with unwanted, stray and abandoned animals. You find you are being stopped in the street, cornered in the supermarket, and once the address of the rescue gets out into the public domain, you will regularly come home or wake up to find boxes of kittens outside your door or dogs tied to your gate. There will be no courtesy phone call from the owner to apologise for leaving them or to offer a donation or give any background history as to their health, personality, or spay status. You are on your own.

You find you are being threatened and emotionally blackmailed if you say you don't have room/funds for more animals. "If you don't take these f***king cats/dogs, I'll starve/drown/dump them," is something you'll hear on a regular basis. With some callers, it's just an idle threat, with others, it's deadly serious. Emotionally it takes its toll. Saying No is difficult as you are acutely aware that in some instances you are the only hope these animals have to stay alive, but say no you must. You must know your limitations, what you can do and more importantly, what you can't do. You will be abused for it. "Aren't you the rescue?" "Isn't that your job?" "You're always out collecting money but when we need help, you can't do anything." The public mistakenly believe or care less that the rescue has endless money, endless time, tons of volunteers and acres of space when in truth you could never have enough of all four.

Couple this with seeing animals suffering the most appalling neglect and abuse on a regular basis. This too has an effect on your emotions. You wouldn't be human if it didn't. Shock, sadness, anger, frustration and outrage are emotions you experience on a regular basis and have to learn to live with and find ways to process and cope with in an effort to continue. Some days are filled with tears of joy but others are filled with tears of sadness.

Throw into this mix the less than complimentary comments from other rescues about what you're doing, what you're not doing, what you should be doing and how you should be doing it and is it any wonder some crack under the pressure.

Under such pressure, it's easy to cave in, make a wrong decision, take a rash chance and suddenly it's all unravelling before your eyes. It can happen so easily. "What's one or two more cats?" you think as you juggle animals in your minds eye. You've two cats going to their new home tomorrow, so yes you'll take those five being threatened with starvation. So you take them in but the home for the two cats falls through, then a fosterer has an emergency and can no longer foster that mum and 6 kittens for you and you have to take them back. Meanwhile someone dumps another mum and litter of kittens at your door. Suddenly you are overwhelmed and out of your depth. You appeal for help but none is forthcoming. You flash urgent messages on Facebook and animal forums begging for foster homes but everyone else is up to their eyes also. That fundraiser you planned didn't bring in as much funds as you'd hoped, some of the volunteers didn't show up. Now, some of the animals are getting sick and you can't afford the vets bills. You feel sick with worry and stress, getting out of bed in the morning is getting harder and harder.

Who do you turn too?

All of us who work in animal rescue in Ireland have so much in common, our experiences are the same. Talking to each other should be an avenue of support and understanding, but is it? We should be able to lift the phone and talk to someone in the same field who will listen, understand and not pass judgement, but can we? Or will we be met with criticism, derision or taunts of "told you so."

If we feel a fellow animal rescuer is in difficulties and needs support, is a heart to heart with a cup of tea at the kitchen table too much to ask or expect? Is rolling up our sleeves and lending a hand beyond our capabilities? After all, we are all in the same boat.

If a bit more compassion and support for our fellow rescuers were two things to come out of what happened in Cork, then at least something good would have been salvaged from that tragic situation.

4 comments:

  1. Thank you for this. I have been haunted by what happened in Cork. I adore animals, and own some rescued cats and a dog. I was heart-broken when I saw those pictures. BUT, I did comment that no-one opens up an animal shelter hoping for that outcome. Whoever set it up was obviously overwhelmed, and I expect that they were ill in some way. You may know the true story. Those animals, at least the ones that survived, will always suffer somewhat from what they went through, but whoever owned that shelter will be suffering too. This is one of the only times that I haven't posted 'hang them' or worse. My heart bleeds for all involved, and I, like you, truly hope that only good can come out of it.
    Nicola

    ReplyDelete
  2. Maureen - wonderful to see this blog. And completely agree with Charlotte too. The cruelty case rescue without doubt started off with the best intentions - I know solid people who volunteered there. And I spoke to the woman earlier this year and nearly took two pregnant cats to the UK for rehoming for her - but the trip was cancelled because I could get enough cats to make the trip worthwhile. I've never met her but she seemed genuine and was certainly looking for help - but it wasn't apparent what dire straights she was in. She's certainly different from your standard intentionally cruel people and from your average collector. I know what it's like to be overwhelmed with rescues and have learned to say no and to network to find others to say yes. And I'm very lucky to have an excellent support group behind me - of friends and rescuers both.

    I can't condone the state of the animals in the case but the vitriol directed at the rescue illustrates to me how easily people look to condemn others, without looking at the particular situation - and without looking at themselves and how much they contribute. I do think that situation has come out of the appalling animal welfare situation in Ireland as a whole - people dumping their animal companions without thought, walking past animals in need, outdated legislation that isn't even supported by the guarda, inadequate cruelty officers (4 for the whole of Ireland), inadequate funding, etc etc.

    Do post my longer comment - it came from the heart.

    And there is a manual for rescue!!! The Feline Advisory Bureau in the UK has two excellent publications - I read them last year and wish I'd read them ten years ago when I started. Highly highly recommended - Cat Rescue Manual http://www.fabcats.org/publications/index.php#crm and Feral Cat Manual (TNR!!) http://www.fabcats.org/publications/index.php#feral

    Thanks for starting this much needed blog. I'm finding a great deal of support between rescues already - but we all need to learn to ask for help when we need it (not as easy as it sounds) - and to recognise when it's needed elsewhere.
    Muriel

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks Nicola and Muriel for commenting. I don't know the true story of what happened but it's interesting to read what you say, Muriel, about the rescue in question.

    I too was shocked at some of the comments made and I also am not condoning what happened to the animals.

    I would hope something good can come out of this. If people have a better understanding of what it's like to run a rescue, if they are more inclined to take responsibility, to make an effort to solve whatever the problem is themselves or indeed if they offer to volunteer at their local rescue, that would at least be something.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Muriels longer post which speaks a lot of truth.

    "What would happen if any of us, as individuals, took in every animal we get told about (because word gets around that we're animal people)? I'm lucky I've a good network of animal lovers as friends and organisations behind me. I've learned to say 'no' cos I know I can't help them all. And I try not to think about the consequences of saying no. And try and find someone else who'll say yes. But, proportionate to the population as a whole, there's not many out there who will say yes.

    I'm not condoning what has happened here in any way. But what if you kept trying to help the animals and weren't on the internet and didn't have a support group and you've run out of money and the vet won't deal with you because you owe them so much and all the other shelters are full? I'm sure most of us would never let anything like this happen but what if?

    If this person started with the best intentions ... what I'm trying to say is ... the problem is the non existent legislation in this country. It's the majority of people who walk past an animal in need - they're outraged by this story but they'll call a shelter rather than take in and pay for treatment for one animal. And they'll leave the animal where they saw it if no shelter will take it.

    I took a cat, Val, to the vets last week. He was so far downhill he died the next day. Reported/rescued even one day earlier he'd have survived. He hung out at Supervalu carpark in Dunmanway. He was known by the staff and the customers. Someone put him on a car bonnet in the sun when he could hardly move. Someone else, probably the car owner, removed him and he couldn't be found when the people who first spotted him went back for him. They finally found him the next day. He had a bad tooth. So he couldn't eat. How long did people walk past him before he got so weak he couldn't hunt, couldn't drink? How many individuals walked past him, didn't help him? He died of toothache and indifference.

    I think the people who walked past him are probably worse than the rescue prosecuted here. I really do. They didn't even try. Someone else'll deal with him. Or he's nothing that matters anyway. If everyone in Ireland rescued one animal, people like this person wouldn't get inundated and be unable to cope, rescue centres wouldn't be skint and unable to cope, the Irish Equine Crisis wouldn't have happened.

    If a significant proportion of the population cared. If legislation wasn't archaic. If the guards enforced the pathetic legislation that does exist. That many animals didn't die and get into that appalling condition overnight at the cruelty case shelter. How many people knew about their condition and did nothing about it? How long did it take for the ISPCA to get involved (NOT a critisism of ISPCA, a criticism of the lack of the public reporting, lack of staff, lack of funding)? How many other people could have taken some of those animals in but didn't?

    This situation is not the fault of one person. Apologies for the dramaticism but it's the fault of a nation. And sorry for rant. Hundreds of people watched a friendly cat called Val fade away slowly over a period of weeks because his tooth hurt. How many people share a blame in this cruelty case and will never even realise? Nuff said."

    ReplyDelete